Guest viewing is limited

Is the Bucatstate the new Hamster Heaven? :-) Debate thread

Maz

Administrator
Admin/Moderator
Messages
25,216
Reaction score
29,589
Points
1,373
A debate and a bit of Hamster cage history :-)

When I first started keeping hamsters about 12 years ago, the Savic Hamster Heaven cage was THE Hamster Heaven – it was seen as huge compared to the average cage of 60cm x 40cm and it was certainly a big improvement for Hamsters. It met the RSPCA guideline of a minimum of 80cm x 50cm at that time. It was one of the most popular cages for many years – partly also because of it’s large front opening door – people could interact with their hamsters easily, Hamsters could come out of the cage easily and it was easy to bond with and tame the hamsters. The majority of hamsters were happy in this cage – some needed more space and showed it.

For many owners we quickly realised – it just wasn’t quite big enough and the 100cm cages from Zooplus in Germany became the norm for Syrian hamsters – the Barney and Alexander cages particularly. They were seen as palaces – the ultimate home for a hamster. And this remained the case for many years, with the Hamster Heaven cage being seen as fine for dwarf hamsters but not for most Syrians. However there was no longer an official guideline for cage size so it became the job of forums like this one, to educate people and encourage them into using larger cages. It was an uphill battle to encourage better welfare conditions for hamsters.

So when two major pet charities produced official guidelines of a minimum size of 100cm x 50cm in about April 2023 there were celebrations within the world of experienced hamster owners. Finally what we knew was right, had been validated and promoted.

Along with this though, was also the encouragement that hamsters needed much deeper bedding, which was a moot point for some. While hamsters do like to dig their own tunnels, many owners had found hamsters happy with just 6” of bedding and a multiroom house that mimicked a burrow – hamsters had a ready-made burrow with the multiroom house and German companies like Rodipet and Getzoo had been making these for a long time. Indeed Rodipet had actually done research in Syria showing the need for such multiroom houses. And they worked very well. The hamsters would build a large nest in the darkest room, and use a toilet in a separate room and have space for hoards. They seemed to like having an ensuite bathroom and everything in its place.

To have deeper bedding means a deeper base on a cage. Most cages only had a 6” base. Historically, the glass aquariums used in Germany and the USA, were prohibitively expensive in the Uk. However the Uk had a large range of excellent barred cages – admittedly most of them from Germany, but then Savic produced a 100cm version of the Hamster Heaven – the Savic Plaza – now known as the Savic Plaza 100. I personally had been pressuring for them to do this for quite some time and then one day a contact from Savic contacted me, discussed it and it became reality. So then it happened. It gradually became THE go to cage for hamster owners, even before the new 100 x 50 guidelines came in, and still is an excellent, reasonably priced cage for a new hamster owner.

We owners devised various ways to achieve deeper bedding, by putting cardboard or grass mats inside the bars, and later aided by a company called Viking Laser making tailor made Perspex panels to fit the cages. And even full Perspex to replace the bars. In the United states, which had never really had any barred cages large enough for hamsters and where glass aquariums were quite affordable, Niteangel appeared and created flatpack wood and Perspex enclosures. Particularly the Niteangel vista with its sloping front, which was the next best thing to a large front opening door on a tank. But at a very high price. I think it was about $300 initially. We in the Uk envied this enclosure – it wasn’t really available in the Uk but it was ok as we had lots of nice large 100cm cages and hamster owners in the US envied our large barred cages. At one point the Savic Plaza became available in the US for a while and there was great excitement.

Owners would look at making similar diy cages with Ikea flatpacks – but these were often significantly more expensive than buying a cage due to the cost of the Perspex or glass, and DIY was not an option for everyone. But it was a way of making a 100cm enclosure.

And then, around mid 2023, a new enclosure gradually came on the market – in an 80cm and a 100cm size. The Bucatstate Perspex and metal tank cage. Bearing in mind, at this stage, most owners still considered 80 x 50cm to be the minimum cage size with 100 x 50cm much better, and many people were getting the 80cm Bucatstate’s initially.

They looked lovely – and still do - a clear view of the hamster all round. And they had a front opening door. A tank with a large front opening door ticked a lot of boxes. However they were also very expensive at £150 to £200 when a cage could be bought for £70 to £80. And even at this time £80 for a cage seemed ridiculously expensive. Pre-pandemic, the 100cm Barney cage was selling for £45 with free shipping. The Bucatstate’s had their teething problems for a year or two as well – issues with door hinges and closures, hamsters chewing them or escaping, Perspex panels bowing or popping out when bedding was in them. Most of this was improved with the Bucatstate 2.

I personally thought they looked amazing but was quite happy using my Savic Plaza cages – I loved the ergonomics of the cage and the large front opening door, the ability to set it up with both ground level enrichment and safe roof runs, and bar attachements, and the ease of use for storing and cleaning, the excellent ventilation and the fact that the bars allowed for the hamster to have closer interaction with the human environment and smell cooking aromas and just feel closer. And I had long been a proponent of – 100cm being the sweet spot – when the cage was large enough, hamsters don’t chew bars. I firmly promote that, from years of experience and having had many hamsters in 100cm cages. If the space is right and they aren't overcleaned, they don’t have that stress so don’t chew bars - exceptions were rare and that was often if the hamster's cage was in a bedroom and they knew you were there at night so it would be to get attention and want to be let out. Usually exceptions were female Syrians, but not all of them. So I was very happy with 100cm barred cages and the idea of spending £150 to £200 on a hamster enclosure, however nice, seemed unthinkable. However I longed for one just that bit bigger.

Many of us for years had wanted a 120cm cage. 100cm was great but – we saw the 120cm rabbit cages and guinea pig cages and wished for a 120cm hamster cage. Some people actually did mesh guinea pig cages to achieve that. At the time I had a particularly active male Syrian who wanted to be out every night, (Raffy), owned the living room and kept me up very late at night as he claimed his territory in the living room for hours and I thought – he could do with something bigger.

I had been in discussions with Savic for some time – about a barred cage that was 120cm or a barred cage with a much deeper base for bedding and they then released the Savic Plaza 120 in about December 2022. Frustratingly it wasn’t available in the Uk for another few months, but as soon as it was, I bought one. I and many others were incredibly excited! A 120cm barred cage FOR HAMSTERS! With hamster bar spacing. I loved that cage, and I still do. It was huge – very deep as well as long. My Syrian boy Raffy also loved the extra space. Although it didn’t stop him wanting to come out and spend all night roaming the living room!

Even better news was, that there was ANOTHER 120cm cage on the way from Savic with a much deeper base. The Savic Aura 120 plexi.

At this stage the Bucatstate was still quite a new thing and also very expensive. Whereas the Savic Plaza 120 was a typical hamster cage and only cost £100 - which was still a lot of money!. I applied my existing Perspex panels to it for the deeper bedding that had just become the new recommendation from the Blue Cross and PDSA.

It was an exciting time – a major UK pet store was stocking two 120cm cages for hamsters. When the one with the deep base came out I was kindly given one to review (having badgered for it to be produced for a few years!). The Savic Aura 120 plexi. The perfect cage that so many hamster owners had wanted for so many years. A deep base that held 10” of bedding, narrow 6.5mm bar spacing so suitable for smaller species, and still that large front opening door and also a large door on top as well.

The bubble burst with the major pet store and they stopped selling the 120cm cages and they became hard to get hold of, and also Bucatstate produced a new 120cm version of their Perspex tank also – the Bucatstate 3 in 100cm and 120cm sizes.

And so, in the past year or so, it seems the Bucatstate has become the new Hamster Heaven – the go to Hamster cage or enclosure that everyone seems to get and seems to have become the standard.

I have mixed feelings about this. It is good that it is easily available, in many countries – Europe, the Uk and the USA. It is good that it is large and holds plenty of deep bedding easily. Most owners consider the ventilation is enough, although more would be better. However, it is a good enclosure and is extremely popular.

So my mixed feelings? The cost. Both Bucatstate enclosures are over £250. Having a hamster as a pet didn’t used to be about cost - it was about bonding, care and love. We could buy second hand cages cheaply – and I will add that you still can! Second hand Savic Plazas. It is wonderful that people want to give their hamsters the best, but I worry about the pressure for those who can't afford a £250 enclosure. Then there is also the cost of filling a large 120cm tank with bedding and the cost of the platforms needed – no bars to screw shelves to so platforms need buying - and all the enrichment needed. I will admit to feeling bah humbug about the idea that hamsters should all have a multiroom house when they have 10” of bedding, because they don’t actually need a multiroom house to mimic a burrow if they just dig a burrow under it and use it as a porch! When they had 6” of bedding they actually used the rooms! One for nesting, one for toileting – and it didn’t collapse on them like a real burrow as it was made of wood!

However it is still nice for them to have a multiroom house as somewhere to go even if they don’t use the rooms and it’s a nice big porch and makes a bit of a platform as well.

So where am I going with these mixed feelings? Well – back to the cost. There are two things. 1) Many people who would be good hamster owners, just cannot afford a £250 cage and another £250 more on bedding and contents. That is £500 to own a hamster minimum taking that route. 2) The reality is there are still vast numbers of families just going to a large major pet chain and buying a hamster and a small own brand cage. And smaller than 80 x 50 even. These people are not on hamster social media sites - they probably don’t ever google anything hamster related or go on any hamster websites. They just buy a hamster and a cage, and are sold all the wrong things. So unless there is legislation, pet stores will still sell small cages.

Some of these owners end up on this forum when they have a problem – the hamster is bar chewing or has chewed a hole in the cage base and escaped. They are worried about the hamster. And they find they need to buy another cage. That is bad enough for new owners when they find they have to spend more money on a bigger, more secure cage to solve the issue. Some of them do indeed go on to spend £250 on a Bucatstate. Many will be looking for a second hand Savic Plaza.

Conclusion:

So – if the Bucatstate is the new Hamster Heaven, the Savic Plaza 100 remains the trusty mini car – the everyman cage – it does the job, it’s inexpensive, it’s functional and provides a perfectly good home for a pet hamster. Adding a bit of cardboard and a few grass mats doesn’t break the bank and it doesn’t cost as much in bedding as a 120cm x 60cm Bucatstate.

So the point I am getting to is – I find it very sad that there now seems to be this large trend, in so many places online, influencing people negatively about barred cages - with information that barred cages are bad, inadequate, ugly or whatever the latest criticism is. And that is not the case.

I will always stand up for barred hamster cages! Some of the criticisms have become ridiculous – not liking to see a hamster behind bars. Well that is no difference to a hamster being behind a Perspex wall – it is a psychological reaction not a pet welfare reaction. On the contrary it could be argued that there is a lot of space between those bars for the hamster to sniff the air in their environment and feel part of the home more closely. An enclosure is an enclosure whether it has bars or whether it is solid sided. Because hamsters need to be kept safe or they would run away and get injured or die.

Admittedly the bases are still not deep enough. However there are now many many more barred cages with deep bases for bedding. It seems the manufacturers of these new 120cm cages with deep bases may have missed the boat however, as the Bucatstate is now king.

The Bucatstate is a wonderful enclosure and suits many people and makes a great home for Hamster. I am just saying that some people still prefer barred cages and they should not be knocked either. These are personal preferences, for many reasons. Whether it be physical stamina and physical ability, just a preference or ease of finding the right space in a home to stand something on, or cost, or many other reasons.

I think it’s great there are now so many 100cm and 120cm options for hamsters and that a section of the world and internet in some countries, accepts that hamsters need a lot of space.

However not everyone is from the USA, Europe or the Uk. There are hamster owners in countries where large cages aren’t available, safe bedding isn’t available.

And that is why a forum like this is important – it’s a place for people to go to get help with finding solutions, where they will not be judged and where they will not feel that the only good way to keep a hamster is to own a Bucatstate tank.

Finally, I know many members on here own Bucatstate’s and it is lovely to see so many wonderful hamster set ups. And it is great that they are so easily available now. And maybe one day I will get one – although I already have 3.5 barred cages so don’t really need one!

This piece really was just to show how fast things have evolved since the Hamster Heaven. The Bucatstate is the new Hamster Heaven. But I am very keen to ensure that people who cannot afford one, do not feel it is the only acceptable option.

So what are your thoughts? Has anyone else come across a lot of anti-barred cages information in places or myths?
It is a personal preference and depends on budget as well.
 
Last edited:
It is a very interesting debatei. Thank you for raising it. Dwarfies are probably less likely to chew so could be accommodated in the wood and perspex cages that are available, some with built in platforms. The falls risk has to be considered for some of these. I think PawHut has started making perspex and metal cages.
 
Extremely interesting debate! I do as you know have a Bucatstate 3 I find it very good. I think with all the guide lines now people just want to do the right thing for their hamster. The hamster is the most important thing here. It's also down to how you want to landscape your enclosure I've found with my enclosure there are things I can't do, for example I can't hang tubes or treats easily. I think if you're a responsible hamster owner both types of enclosure can work 🥰
 
Extremely interesting debate! I do as you know have a Bucatstate 3 I find it very good. I think with all the guide lines now people just want to do the right thing for their hamster. The hamster is the most important thing here. It's also down to how you want to landscape your enclosure I've found with my enclosure there are things I can't do, for example I can't hang tubes or treats easily. I think if you're a responsible hamster owner both types of enclosure can work 🥰
I think that is spot on @Vanessa1 - thank you. People want to know what's right and do the right thing and the Bucatstate has approval everywhere, gives them confidence it is safe for a hamster and escape-proof, so they know exactly what to do for a Hamster. And it's great people are prepared to spend a good sum of money to have things just right for the hamster.

So while it may not be cheap, it saves time, research, decisions. I'd also like to change the analogy above from mini to Ford Fiesta! A mini isn't the same now :-). It is great that it is available though.
 
I have the exact same thoughts as you and I am really glad of the stance you have taken for this forum. My age might be showing but 10 years ago when I first started having hamsters, I remember the effort was on getting people out of crittertrail cages -- so bin cages were the ones promoted because it was the most affordable option. At that time, I had a detolf which was one of the more popular large cages.

I recently got back into having hamsters again and it is not surprising to see that the IKEA detolf is no longer recommended, I barely see any bin cages too. It's always good to see changes of course, but I do not like the culture which has taken over much of other groups. I understand that they are looking out for the hamster's wellbeing but it can be a little unforgiving. I have the bucatstate 1.2m cage but I would never judge or tell anyone else that they have to change their hamster's enclosure because like you mentioned, it is expensive. (On a separate note, I always wonder why niteangel and bucatstate are so expensive in Western countries, probably due to shipping and taxes.)

Anyway, I just wanted to thank you again for creating a group that has space for others with different enclosures!
 
I also remember that :-) Bin cages are still quite popular in the USA for dwarf hamsters but not really for Syrians. They kind of went out in the Uk when the minimum cage size increased to 100cm x 50cm because there literally aren't any bins big enough in the Uk! Unlike the US where there are some very large ones available. It's a shame as it was such a cheap option with a little bit of diy, so people could afford to keep more than one hamster or not be put off by cost. A detolf was my dream for a long time! But by the time I had two hamsters I didn't really have the space for one. I think it was the dream cage for a long time. There are still people using them and they are still suitable. - the problem is Ikea don't sell them any more so I guess there will be less and less of them available second hand as time goes on.

I am curious to know how much the Bucatstate costs is in non Western countries! I mean - the metal frame is not much different to that for garage shelves. And perspex, admittedly can be a bit expensive, but I'd have thought the parts generally would not be that expensive, certainly no more than say £100 in bulk.
 
I also remember that :-) Bin cages are still quite popular in the USA for dwarf hamsters but not really for Syrians. They kind of went out in the Uk when the minimum cage size increased to 100cm x 50cm because there literally aren't any bins big enough in the Uk! Unlike the US where there are some very large ones available. It's a shame as it was such a cheap option with a little bit of diy, so people could afford to keep more than one hamster or not be put off by cost. A detolf was my dream for a long time! But by the time I had two hamsters I didn't really have the space for one. I think it was the dream cage for a long time. There are still people using them and they are still suitable. - the problem is Ikea don't sell them any more so I guess there will be less and less of them available second hand as time goes on.

I am curious to know how much the Bucatstate costs is in non Western countries! I mean - the metal frame is not much different to that for garage shelves. And perspex, admittedly can be a bit expensive, but I'd have thought the parts generally would not be that expensive, certainly no more than say £100 in bulk.
Ooo that’s interesting! Maybe because I hang around in Syrian hamsters’ spaces so that could be why. Definitely the discontinuation of the detolf contributed to it, and also because there are more commercially available large cages too!

I paid about 270 SGD for my 1.2m Bucatstate which is about 157 GBP! For another reference, I bought the Niteangel wheel directly from Taobao for the equivalent of 23 GBP!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maz
That is interesting that most of the cost is import and shipping charges (presumably) - which makes sense. Glad you can get it cheaper! The detolf was a really inexpensive option though at £40 - then it went up to £60. Shame they discontinued it. And yes Niteangel wheels are SO expensive in the Uk. Unfortunately all the good wheels in the Uk either come from the US or Germany so cost more - except the Trixie plastic 28cm wheel! Which is still inexpensive even though it's from Germany. And it's a good basic wheel and mostly quiet!
 
I think holding any cage to the "Hamster Heaven" standard is going to cause issues. I love bin cages (big, cheap, & customizable) but some hamsters are chew fiends and simply can't live in a plastic house. Barred cages work amazing for ventilation, but some hamsters are going to chew/climb infinitely on the bars and would do better in a solid-walled enclosure. Tanks are big and generally good quality, but are heavy and on the expensive side. Our standards are always updating & changing (which is why I love this forum - we can always discuss the best guidelines) and will depend on both the hamster and the owner. I would personally probably recommend a solid-walled cage before I recommend a barred cage, just because, in my experience, my hamsters have loved chewing on bars even with more than enough space. With all that said, if a barred cage works for you, I encourage you to keep using it!

Anyway, who wants to start an ethical hamster cage company with me in America so we don't have to pay for import and shipping charges? :LOL:
 
I love barred cages as I feel more connected to the hamster. I can feed through the bars and talk through the bars and I remember years ago moving my roborovski, Flower to a barred cage (Grosvenor) from a solid cage (maxi duna multy). She looked all round (all her old bedding was there and her house, in the exact same layout) and then went up to the bars and sniffed the air.

That image has stayed with me and it is really why I prefer bars.

The maxi duna multy was brilliant for hamster viewing and I now love the omlet cage (88 x 56 and 49 high) because it has perspex and bars. Wish they had made it 100 x 56 though.
 
I think it's more of a Uk thing perhaps to have had positive experiences with barred cages :-) Because they were the main option for a long time - apart from detolfs or maxi Duna's. I have never had a hamster bar chew. With one blip and that was a specific period of extreme stress. When our first Hamster Charlie had been left with a pet sitter for 10 days, along with his cage - which was basically the same as a Hamster Heaven except it was the Mickey 2XL. Which wasn't that large at 80 x 50 but it was his first cage and recommended at the time. When he came home after that 10 day period he seemed very stressed and started bar chewing - it was very upsetting actually. I had the cage door open all evening with the playpen round it so he could come and go as he pleased and he was just basically doing stressy circuits. It went on for two weeks. What stopped it in the end, ironically, was a full cage clean. I suspected he could smell the other hamsters from the pet sitters - a female in particular who apparently climbed the outside of his cage. His cage had a faint aroma of vinegar afterwards, which he sniffed cautiously, and then went back to normal!

So that was a specific stress that caused it and I realise if he hadn't had bars he wouldn't have been able to chew them, but then I think he would maybe still have been stressed in a solid sided cage - or maybe not.

All my hamsters after that, apart from one robo, were in 100cm barred cages and none of them bar chewed or bar climbed - they seemed happy with the space. My maverick male would do it briefly if he saw me just before 10pm to demand to be let out! That is all. I take the point though - no bars - no bar chewing. But I do think it's something that is related to stress mainly - cage too small, something upsetting them. There are times though when they can do it to try and tell you something important - like if their water is empty and get your attention. I assume in a tank they would paw against the side to try and tell you something important.

So my experiences have all been positive. Having said that I've only had Syrians and Robos and some dwarf hamsters can climb bars and monkey bar - but as long as the cage isn't too high .............

But my feeling was that 100cm was the sweet spot where they didn't bar chew to get out - with the odd exception who needed more space.

Having said that I like the idea of a solid sided one - as long as it has a big front door like the Plaza cages :-) I couldn't get on with just top opening only but then that was with an 80cm tank, not a larger one. It's probably party why the Bucatstate's are so popular as they have a front opening door - but it's a long reach down from it with about 30cm of bedding under it. Although personally I still like the ventilation from bars as well! I'm happy with the hybrid type as well - perspex base and barred top - as long as they have that front opening door. I remember people diy-ing old cage doors onto the front of bin cages!

Some people do still make bin cages in the Uk by slicing the end of two bins and joining them together - but it's quite a bit of diy.

Maybe we should start plugging bin cages more! I think the other reason they sort of disappeared a bit in the Uk was because of the pax and platsa diy options from Ikea, which were easier!

As @elephanthamster says - there is no perfect cage or enclosure, for both hamster and human!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top